Scotus Says Jury Not A Judge Must Decide Facts For Punishment
Andre Haymond got a break in his child pornography case, as the U.S. Supreme Court said his sentence for violating probation should be decided by a jury. In United States v. Haymond, the justices said the defendant’s sentence was “unconstitutional and unenforceable” because the punishment exceeded his original sentence and the judge added prison time without a jury finding. A jury must decide every fact that is “essential to an individual’s punishment,” the divided court said....