This case in four words: loose lips claim clips.

But then there was booze.

As the police officers walked out with the weapons, Block drunkenly voiced his objection to the seizure of his property. He continued to demand the return of his guns on the way to jail.

If that weren’t enough, after he befriended his cell mate over games of chess, he confided that he wished he had hidden his weapons in the baby’s room instead. Unsurprisingly, the cell mate snitched.

Two confessions were enough for the judge and jury to convict Bloch of violating both § 922(g)(1) and § 922(g)(9). He was sentenced to consecutive terms for the two counts, for a total of 400 months.

Sufficiency of the Evidence

Hah. Let’s run down the elements:

  • Prior convictions? Undisputed.
  • Firearms traveled in, or affected interstate commerce? Undisputed.
  • Possession? Well, there was that drunken “give me back my guns” stuff. But that was totally just unreliable booze-speak. The court says “in vino veritas.” Bloch argues insufficient evidence. Oh wait, you also confessed to your cell mate. Two confessions? That’ll do.

Concurrent Sentences Violate the Guidelines

Red herring, bro. Just ask the government.

Our Bad

The government pointed out the real error in this case: multiplicity.

Though the government is free to pursue multiple theories at trial for a single possession incident, the defendant can’t be punished twice for the same possession offense – even if he was doubly disarmed by the law. The allowable unit of prosecution is the act of possession, not the number of statutory provisions that disqualify the defendant from firearm possession. Ditto for multiple weapons possessed simultaneously.

The Court commended the government for forthrightly acknowledging the unnoticed mistake and remanded the case for resentencing, as the statutory maximum sentence for the merged convictions is 120 months.

Related Resources:

  • United States v. John W. Bloch III (Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals)
  • Multiplicity: More Than a Bad Michael Keaton Movie (FindLaw’s Tenth Circuit Blog)
  • Are Edgar County Jail Conditions Cruel and Unusual? (FindLaw’s Seventh Circuit Blog)

You Don’t Have To Solve This on Your Own – Get a Lawyer’s Help

Civil Rights

Block on Trump’s Asylum Ban Upheld by Supreme Court

Criminal

Judges Can Release Secret Grand Jury Records

Politicians Can’t Block Voters on Facebook, Court Rules